(From: Stuart Schoenfeld)
Haaretz
By Eitan Bekerman
The large green Isuzu jeep climbs and descends the hills, leaving a trail of
dust behind it, while the MIRS telephone receives and sends fragmented calls.
In the back part of the vehicle are barred cages suitable for alligators and
snakes. Aryeh Keller - small, solid, somewhat potbellied since he stopped
smoking, his face scorched from the summer heat - confidently grabs the
steering wheel while exchanging coarse but friendly curses with his
interlocutors, who are nature preservation colleagues or friends from the
police, as he continues to speed along toward his goal: rescuing baby finches.
Why do the bad guys, the ones whom the "sheriff" is after, go after finches, of
all birds? Because of the "mules." Anyone unfamiliar with the mule is missing
something. Keller (whose first name means "lion" in English) explains: "A mule
in this context is a cross between a finch and a canary - a bird that is a
wonderful singer and has beautiful colors as well. There's a lot of demand for
these birds, they're worth a lot, and there are people whose work is to trap
the finch nestlings in order to breed mules."
This is an entire industry. The trappers of baby finches - henceforth "the
collectors" - do their work in a particularly wicked way, which we'll get to
soon. The trapped birds are transferred to breeders, who keep and mate them in
special warehouses in various parts of the country. From there the mules are
sent to retailers or to private customers. The more beautiful the mule, and the
more classical its song, the more expensive it is. An especially fine mule can
be sold for thousands of shekels. Worthy of mention is the mule Abu Khalil, a
native of Hebron, who sang like no other mule ever, and whose worth was
estimated at tens of thousands of shekels.
Keller says that the number of baby finches that are caught is estimated in the
hundreds of thousands. "Recently," he explains, "this has become an unusually
widespread phenomenon, in Israel and in the territories. Don't forget that many
of them die on the way. In general, there is a bottomless market for caged
birds, and mules are the biggest hit now. So you need finches, and everywhere
in Israel there are collectors who hunt them. They are actually emptying the
country of this beautiful, very Israeli bird."
How does one catch such a large number of finches? There are ways. "During the
incubation season the finches gather near water sources. When the nestlings
hatch and are only starting to learn to fly, people place traps there. The
collectors put an adult finch next to the water source tied to a stick, they
bind it with a wing harness, and that is the bait. On both sides of the stick
they attach two sheets of plastic and a net, 3 x 2 meters, which are attached
to a rope, and they wait for the right moment."
The innocent nestlings, who have just begun learning to fly, come to drink water
and get into trouble. "They are attracted to the adult finch," explains Keller,
"try to reach it, and then with one pull of the rope the plastic sheets fold,
and dozens of baby birds are trapped inside the net. This is repeated 30 or 40
times, sometimes more. No method is unacceptable to the collectors. Sometimes
when the female is still sitting on the eggs, and goes down for a moment to
drink water, or when she sees a male and flies to him, they trap them, too.
Everything for money."
It's not easy an easy life for 54-year-old Keller, who is national supervisor of
the Israel Nature and Parks Protection Authority (INPPA), and is responsible for
preventing the import and trade of wildlife. His difficult goal is to get to
collectors all over the country, so he concentrates on finding the warehouses
of the finches and mules. How? Intelligence. Over the years he has developed a
very broad network of connections.
"Now, for example," he says, before dialing a phone number on his cell phone,
"I'm going to check the address of one guy, Yitzhak something, in Jaffa, with
the police. Often the wholesalers with the warehouses are criminals who are
familiar to the police from other areas."
The conversation is short, full of security codes, and at the end Keller
explains: "The nice guy I spoke to now is the intelligence coordinator of the
Jaffa police. He's checking for me whether the target happens to be a police
source, which means we have to be more careful; he's finding out for me of
course whether there really is such a person at that address, he completes the
investigations so we won't end up with a farce, so there'll be successes."
Intelligence network
Wherever Keller goes, he remembers the law, which is worded as follows: "No one
can trade in a wild animal, or in part of it, or in its offspring, in Israel or
abroad. And the law defines, of course, which animals are wild, in accordance
with the Washington Convention (on International Trade in Endangered Species of
Wild Fauna and Flora), to which Israel has been a signatory since 1984, to our
satisfaction."
For the purpose of his battle against illegal trade, Keller has established his
own national intelligence network, which is semi-clandestine and includes
people in the field, ordinary citizens, plus the spearhead: the Israel Police.
"Police units, elite units, such as the Tel Aviv area unit, for example - I
have personal ties there. Let's say they go on a search at the home of a target
who is known as a thief, they've finished searching for the stolen property and
the heroin and all that, have already hit on him. Then they look for animals
for me. Let's say they find a snake or a monkey, immediately they'll say
'Aryeh, come.' I'm on call for them at all hours of the day and night, seven
days a week."
So what will sheriff Keller do with the snake that was found in the criminal's
home? Here we come to another aspect of his job: his connections with every zoo
and petting zoo around the country, which were created during his dozens of
years as a supervisor for the INPPA. After all, someone has to protect and care
for the animals that he saves, and therefore, while driving, he conducts the
following conversation with one of the caretakers at the Nahariya zoo:
Keller: "I have two water snakes for you, from Thailand."
Caretaker: "What are water snakes from Thailand?"
Keller: "It's a type of nonpoisonous snake from Thailand."
Caretaker: "Does it stink?"
Keller: "No, it doesn't stink. It's very good for display."
Caretaker: "Great, so I probably need a wet display, with a pool."
Keller: "Yes, your small pool. And I'm also bringing two young alligators."
Caretaker: "What do you mean by young?"
Keller: "Young means half a year, something like that."
Caretaker: "How long?"
Keller: "About 30 centimeters. They're for display, miss."
Caretaker: "Of course for display - why, did you think I was taking them home?"
Keller: "It's best if you come to my home in Karkur, to take them."
Caretaker: "Oh, okay, okay, so you need us to come to you?"
Keller: "I'm in the Rosh Ha'ayin area now, if you come to me in Karkur in two
hours you'll get both coffee and all the animals."
Caretaker: "Okay, let me just speak to Yigal, he's a little busy, we'll see if
he ..."
Keller: "Dear, for your information, the Haifa zoo wants to come to me now."
Caretaker: "No problem, no problem, we'll come. I'll speak to Yigal.
Keller: "Good. 'Bye, sweetheart."
Caretaker: "Yalla, 'bye."
That evening two Siamese water snakes and two young alligators joined the
display at the Nahariya zoo.
Legendary trapper
Aryeh Keller is a great expert on reptiles, after years of being the assistant
of the legendary Heinrich Mendelssohn, the founder of the zoological garden at
Tel Aviv University.
"I dealt with reptiles all my life, from age zero, but when I came to Prof.
Mendelssohn, I was still a retarded child in the field," he says in his
somewhat brusque style. "Mendelssohn provided the scientific foundation, thanks
to him I am familiar today with all the reptiles in Israel, inside out." Many of
the snakes and alligators that he catches spend time in the zoological garden,
at least as a way station on their way to being displayed in Nahariya.
Keller spent his childhood in Yehud and later in Atlit, or rather mainly in the
fields surrounding them. He was one of those kids who comes home with a little
snake and a mischievous smile. Already in 1987 he was a supervisor for the
INPPA in Sinai; indeed there are few people who can compete with his experience
and his network of contacts, certainly in the area of reptiles and how to catch
them.
There is a reason why over the years he reached the very top, and also holds the
title of "person responsible for snake catchers on behalf of the INPPA." He has
developed unique methods of trapping not only for catching snakes but songbirds
and bats as well. He has his own tricks that he teaches his students.
First thing in the morning we spend together, he got a call and, on his own,
collected eight vipers in the fields of Binyamina. Two days later, he will be
giving a course for snake catchers. "It's important to provide an orderly
solution for this matter, because snakes get into people's homes. Not everyone
can be a collector of snakes and reptiles, you have to be very familiar with
the field. There are about 300 certified collectors in the country, most of
them connected to us, and we try to provide a solution for everyone. If someone
collects snakes and doesn't know what to do with them, we'll take care of them."
There is almost no species of snake that has not been imported, legally or
illegally, to slither about in the Holy Land. "Cobras, mambas, bamboo vipers,"
Keller enumerates some of them, "very poisonous and very dangerous snakes are
imported here, by private snake lovers or travelers returning from the East,
but mainly by professional smugglers. There's always a market for them."
Israeli law prohibits private citizens from importing or keeping poisonous
snakes at home, "because the public good comes first," explains the sheriff,
but the battle with the smugglers and the growers is endless. "Sometimes
they're just naive people who don't really understand," he says, "but for some
it's a business. And when you get into this area of smuggling, of crime, you
know where you begin, but not where you'll end up. There are many kinds of
problems with the people who deal with snakes. One of them even murdered
another collector (Harel Hirschtick of Kibbutz Deganya Bet was convicted of the
murder of Yaakov Sela, the guru of many snake collectors in Israel, who had an
affair with Hirschtick's mother; the motive for the murder was a financial
debt). From my experience, I haven't come across anyone who deals with
reptiles, including me, who isn't somewhat weird. Sometimes in a nice way,
sometimes it's a serious disturbance."
Latest 'hit'
Keller leads the battle against smuggling animals into Israel. There are animals
that are not from rare or dangerous species, which may be brought into the
country, "but every single animal has to have the permission of the INPPA, and
of course you pay a token fee to the authority and V.A.T. and you need
documents, and it's too much for certain people, so they take shortcuts. In
other words, they smuggle."
The latest "hit" in the field, according to Keller, is red-eared turtles. "This
is a swamp turtle," he explains, "which is very aggressive and dominant. You
release it into water sources, it will kill everything around it and then
remain alone. They are brought here when they're the size of a shekel coin,
they grow to 20 or 30 times their original size, and in the end people release
them into the wild. Those red-eared turtles are a plague. Children raise them -
for them it's neither a fish nor a snake, but a cute little turtle, and then
when they grow they throw them into rivers, fish pools, everywhere. And they
survive.
"Those who take shortcuts only bring a few shoe boxes in from Turkey, where the
red-eared turtle costs maybe NIS 2, and bring them to Israel, where it costs
NIS 20, and on 1,000 tiny turtles the traders make NIS 18,000. Tens of
thousands of these turtles are brought into Israel every year. I catch them in
packages of hundreds, and recently I caught 1,200 in one shot. Many turtles are
also smuggled here from Florida, the soft-shell turtle, which is a cousin of the
Israeli turtle. There's a good market for them, too."
What else flows in?
"Aside from the reptiles, there's a lot of smuggling of parrots, regular
smuggling of monkeys, of mammals. The annual loot comes to thousands of birds,
dozens of squirrels, snakes - there is virtually no animal that they haven't
tried to bring into the country. There's also a small number of tiger cubs.
There was one flight attendant who smuggled tiger cubs for a living. There are
tourists coming from the Far East who end their trip by smuggling several
animals in their pockets."
Let's say you've returned from Thailand with a little monkey, to whom would you
sell it?
"Usually they know exactly to whom to transfer it, and if they don't know, then
they come in to find out - and then they get to me."
Apparently, Keller's comments conceal a hint of another kind of information
source in his complex intelligence network. In any case, Keller is a one-man
band, and his battle against crime is complex indeed: "First of all, we receive
initial information, and then I locate the target, ascertain information with
the police intelligence coordinator, coordinate positions with the police,
gather intelligence prior, get a search warrant in court, and join the police
on the ground. I invite the team, mainly detectives. We arrive and say, 'Hello,
sir, we have a search warrant here ...,' and usually the perpetrator already
knows why we've come."
And that's just the beginning: "And then I take testimony on the spot, I do the
investigation. After we catch them I send the animals for rehabilitation, and
deal with the rest of their lives. At the same time I am in effect the
investigator in a criminal case, as well as the chief witness for the
prosecution, and in effect the actual prosecutor in court. You don't have to be
a lawyer in order to be a prosecutor, it's enough to be familiar with the
material, and I am."
The plague of illegal trade in animals is spreading among all the social
classes. From amateur mule breeders in poor neighborhoods up to the highest
income brackets. Keller: "Just for your information, how much does a pair of
palm cockatoo parrots cost? How much should an incubating pair cost? $100,000,
habibi. And these parrots don't talk. I've caught these smugglers, of course.
It's for people who order them specially, they have this obsession, and are
very wealthy people. Some of it is legitimate money, some of it is black
market. Is there any shortage of billionaires here who will spend NIS 100,000
on a pair of these cockatoos? It's the wealthiest 1/1,000th of the population
who are involved in this. They also pay for the entire smuggling route; there
are professionals who do the work for them and they get the merchandise
delivered to their home. To Savyon, to Kfar Shmaryahu, to Herzliya Pituah. To
them it's a sport, but to me it's a crime! But lately there has been a steep
decline in this area."
Why a decline?
"Because of avian flu. The millionaires are afraid of catching it."
Ivory scare
Keller covers long distances all over the country with his green Isuzu, and in
the city, too. On the way to his favorite hummus place in Jaffa, a way station
before he goes in to arrange something in the neighborhood police station, he
slows down near a shop that has two huge elephant tusks at the entrance? Could
it be? After all, trading in wild animal parts is also against the law. "Here,"
he says, pointing at the shop, "we once conducted a police search. We received
information and came here, but it turned out that these tusks are made of wood.
A decoration," he says laughing.
It's true that he and his colleagues are not always successful, especially when
it comes to ivory. "I received a report about some classy shop in a luxury
hotel, where there are a lot of ivory statues. So I did a search there, and it
turned out that they are in fact ivory articles, but from mammoth tusks. It
turns out that they found a huge area of mammoth herds in Siberia, and they
trade freely in their ivory. There is a large market for that. At Ben-Gurion
airport we once found a shipment of mammoth ivory worth hundreds of thousands
of dollars. It comes from Bangkok in large containers. The Siamese do all kinds
of work on mammoth ivory: drawings, engravings, collages, and sell it for a lot
of money. The problem is that it's hard to differentiate between elephant ivory
and mammoth ivory, because the only difference is in the angle of the tusks. And
I'm not a big expert in either elephants or mammoths."
Did you have any successes with ivory?
"Yes, of course. For example, in an antique shop at the entrance to some kibbutz
I found two large tusks. The information came from someone who had visited the
shop, reported to us, and we really let the owner have it. We did the same to
the woman who had sold it to him - some woman from Tel Aviv who had connections
to the foreign service."
The alligator breeders, on the other hand, are not connected to any foreign
service. Usually they are less established people, like the guy who received a
pregnant female alligator as a gift, and managed to give away dozens of her
offspring as holiday gifts among the top criminals, before he himself was shot
to death. Many of the alligators were found by the police (guess who did the
work behind the scenes?), but some of the criminals claimed that they had found
the reptiles while they were still small on the banks of the Yarkon River in Tel
Aviv. Because this is a matter of public welfare and every possibility must be
examined, Keller and his friends spent several nights patrolling the banks of
the river, flashlights in hand, waiting for the alligator to venture forth in
the darkness. It never did.
Keller prefers to stumble here and there rather than ignore any piece of
information that comes into his hands, even the most fragmentary bits.
Otherwise, how would he have caught a 84-centimeter-long alligator in Nahal
Alexander about a year ago, when the rumor of its existence came from an
unknowledgeable hiker?
Since he is the equivalent of an elite commando unit in his field, the sheriff
is also involved in handling thefts. Or as he puts it: "I provide a very good
solution to the problem of the theft of animals as well. Did someone steal a
parrot from you? The police will not solve your problem. I will. They call me
from the police: 'Aryeh, they've stolen a parrot here, maybe you know
something, maybe you can help,' and when they catch stolen parrots they bring
them to me, so that I can find the owner. Then I make the connection and return
it to its owner."
This is perhaps the place to mention that illegal iguanas are also handled by
Keller, and some of them have been caught, but this is not the case when it
comes to piranhas and other dangerous or illegal fish. "I also catch piranhas
if I can," says Keller, who is quick to praise his colleagues from the naval
commando unit, who assist in this area. "But when it comes to trade in fish -
that is the fisheries department. They do excellent work there in the
department. That's not my field."
A country of stupidity
Keller emphasizes that it is both possible and permissible to trade in animals
in accordance with the rules of the Washington Convention, but it is strictly
forbidden to trade in endangered species, even if you represent a zoo. "That's
the strictest level of the convention, which comes to protect chimpanzees,
gorillas, elephants, animals of that kind. But there is also a second level,
which permits trade, as in species of parrots and reptiles, but only in their
offspring. In other words, it is forbidden to grab a parrot from the tree and
to trade in it, but if the parrot was born in some children's zoo then you can
sell it, with a legal document of course. With the documents you have an
indication where they come from, who the parents are, how many generations, and
then it's possible to coordinate and keep track of them. As with dogs and cats.
Our battle is against the large numbers of people who engage in trade without a
permit."
Keller is quite satisfied with the "improvement in public awareness" regarding
criminal activity involving animals, but he is not always pleased with the
severity of punishment. "The most common range of fines for smuggling reptiles
is NIS 7,500 to NIS 25,000. Sometimes there is a suspended sentence, and there
have been some who sat in prison for a while, but the law here is still not
anchored as in the United States, where it's a federal statute. There one goes
straight to prison for a considerable period of time for smuggling. Here it's
the land of milk and honey and stupidity. Everyone has some kind of a meeting
and issues regulations, it's all to cover their asses."
Are there politicians who show special interest in this area?
"Oh, we had an excellent lobbyist in the Knesset, but he left in order to take
care of his sick father. Omri Sharon. It was in his soul and in his genes. If
he hadn't been an MK, he would have been a INPPA supervisor."
If I may get back to the mules, there's something I didn't understand. What do
you do with all the finch nestlings that you rescue?
"The ones that can't fly I keep in my house in Karkur. I have a four-meter cage,
and they stay there until they slowly learn to fly. Sometimes it takes days and
sometimes weeks. When I see that the nestling has learned to fly, I release it
into the wild. If you've taken them and released them when they don't yet know
how to fly, you've killed them. So I take care of them in my house."